Record ids. D-6-n is a Week 6 decision, J-n a journal entry, F-0n a review finding, DR6-n a data request, A-n an assumption; all are in the engagement record.
D6, part 1 of 3. Final version. Rulings are by Daniel Vetsko (engagement owner). Facts come from the Week 6 record (my-work/week-6/state-live.md; look up any id with kit_tools.py query). Where a number is a count from the record, it says so. Version 2 drops when each stage happened (D-6-63), because it does not bear on how the work is done again, and adds the close-out (section 7). Effort hours were not measured, so this log reports counts and order, never effort.
| Phase | What happened | Where to look |
|---|---|---|
| Scoping and scaffold | 22 scoping decisions (D-6-1 to D-6-22), the week scaffolded, a blank-shell scout sandbox set up (D-6-9, D-6-15 to D-6-18) | J-001 |
| Scout run | A sandbox build with no client data: a 32-concept register, four framework files, an engine, 21 QA checks, a ten-company synthetic portfolio, a query pack. Its proposals became the owner's agenda | my-work/experiments/blank-shell-disclosure-v1/final-report.md; J-002, J-003 |
| G1 spec | Read the scout, the data room (250 files), the protocol and the frozen weeks; wrote the charter (15 rules), data map, 20 assumptions and the spec; ten owner rulings; signed (J-021) | J-004 to J-021 |
| Build | Intake, engine copy, framework verification, D2 to D5, two separate-session tests of the query pack | J-023 to J-044 |
| G2 results | Gate checks, reviewer packets, two reviewers, one confirmation pass, signed (J-056) | J-045 to J-056 |
| G3 handoff | Process log, Week 1 reconciliation, pricing reflection, hand-off notes; frozen (J-059) | J-057 to J-060 |
| Close-out | Every open item closed or handed to Northwood; Scope 3, PCAF and the exposure by fund built; all outputs reissued as v2 under a final gate | Section 7; D-6-60 to D-6-67 |
| Guess | Result |
|---|---|
| 1 One row per company, concept and period | Holds after the malformed-row repair and the slug join |
| 2 Scope 2 location-based and market-based kept apart | Holds; market-based is not calculated (DR6-05) |
| 3 One dollar loss per company for a named scenario | Broken: Week 5's effect is a ranged forward figure; the range sits on the data row and a range token prints it |
| 4 Targets carry a baseline year and method | Broken: no company has a target |
| 6 Governance names one responsible body | Broken: no body exists at any company |
| 7 One sign-off contact per company | Partly: roles range from CEO to VP of Risk; two companies name two people |
| 8 Sector plus size band does not single a company out | Broken: four sectors hold one company; descriptors split by fund (D-6-57) |
| 9 One fixed qualification sentence | Confirmed by the protocol |
| 10 Revenue per company in USD millions | Holds; the period (twelve months to January 2026) differs from the emissions year |
| 11 and 12 EU LP requests and EU facts | Unsupported: no EU LP is named |
| 13 Narrative figures are tokens | Holds; count and range tokens were added |
| 14 Stable company ids | Broken in two source files; a join map resolves it |
| 15 Earlier disclosures exist | Confirmed absent; Year 1 |
| 16 Board-page effect wording is a fixed line | Replaced by real effects from Weeks 4 and 5 |
| 20 Public peer figures per peer and metric | Broken for company-level peers; ENERGY STAR site benchmarks for two companies (D-6-58) |
| 22 California business test answerable yes or no | Not answerable from the data room; a legal question |
The remaining guesses (5, 17, 18, 19, 21 and 23) stay untested or are legal: they are on the assumptions register (A-14, A-20).
The owner ruled on every open item (D-6-60 to D-6-67):
my-work/week-6/fund-level/library/methodology/scope3-pcaf-method-v1.md.Portfolio edition: Kith Climate cohort case, fictional client.