|Kith Consulting
← All documentsPortfolio edition · fictional client
01The answer

What matters most, and what to do about it

One page for the whole portfolio: the matrix says which exposures matter; the ranking says what to do first, what it costs and when it pays back.

Of 46 exposures across the ten companies, 5 are large (15% of EBITDA or more) and 21 are likely (35% or more over the hold). 18 initiatives are sized: 3 protect revenue the companies earn today, 1 protects revenue not yet won and 14 are efficiency measures.

46
exposures on the matrix
2
likely and large: mitigate now
3
unlikely but large: hedge or insure
18
initiatives sized, ranked by payback

Report date October 9, 2026All ten companies, priority four marked ★† Kith estimate, see the note at the foot of the page

02The matrix

Which exposures are large, and which are likely

This is the same matrix as in the client deck and, at its default thresholds, the explorer. It uses the everything-lost case for customer data requests; carbon-price scenarios are left off because they overlap the energy line.

How to read it: every dot is one exposure at one company. Left to right is the chance it happens over the remaining hold; bottom to top is how big it is against that company's EBITDA. The dashed lines are Northwood's own cut-offs. Dot colour is the cell it sits in; a dark ring marks a priority company; the numbered dots are the large exposures listed beside the matrix. Hover any dot for its detail.

0.01%0.1%1%5%15%30%100%0%25%50%75%100%chance over the remaining holdimpact, % of EBITDA (log scale)Hedge or insureMitigate nowDeprioritizeAccept and monitor53412
Mitigate now2Likely and large. Capital and management time go here first.
Hedge or insure3Unlikely but large. Transfer the risk: insurance, hedges, contract terms.
Accept and monitor19Likely but small. Watch the trend; do not spend capital on it yet.
Deprioritize22Unlikely and small. Note it; revisit once a year.

The numbered exposures

1Harvest Ridge · customer data requirement: $11.3M, 49% of EBITDA, 50% chance
First move: respond to the customers' data requests: item 2 on the ranked list, cost $54K, pays back in 18 to 33 days.
2Pinnacle · customer data requirement: $8.4M, 42% of EBITDA, 22% chance
First move: respond to the customers' data requests: item 1 on the ranked list, cost $9K, pays back in 9 to 18 days.
3Sterling · customer data requirement: $10.9M, 36% of EBITDA, 50% chance
First move: respond to the customers' data requests: item 18 on the ranked list, cost $9K, pays back in 1 to 2 days.
4Harvest Ridge · sole-source supplier: $4.1M, 18% of EBITDA, 5% chance
First move: qualify a second source or hold buffer stock for the sole-source input; the cost is not sized.
5Sterling · sole-source supplier: $4.6M, 15% of EBITDA, 5% chance
First move: qualify a second source or hold buffer stock for the sole-source input; the cost is not sized.

The story: most exposures are likely but small or unlikely and small, so they need watching, not capital. 5 are large: Harvest Ridge (customer data requirement, $11.3M, 49% of EBITDA); Pinnacle (customer data requirement, $8.4M, 42% of EBITDA); Sterling (customer data requirement, $10.9M, 36% of EBITDA); Harvest Ridge (sole-source supplier, $4.1M, 18% of EBITDA); Sterling (sole-source supplier, $4.6M, 15% of EBITDA). Those are where management time and money should go first.

Not on the matrix: the company reported no loss or no exposure (6)
  • Meridian Business Solutions · weather events reported: no loss
    The company reports its weather events caused no loss: work rerouted; client impact negligible (the company's questionnaire, line 160).…
  • Keystone Behavioral Health · customer data requirement none reported
    No exposure carried; a status of 'none reported' is not a zero estimate
  • NovaCare Health Partners · customer data requirement none reported
    No exposure carried; a status of 'none reported' is not a zero estimate
  • Patriot Staffing · customer data requirement none reported
    No exposure carried; a status of 'none reported' is not a zero estimate
  • Trident IT Solutions · weather events reported: no loss
    The company reports its weather events caused no loss: UPS and generator covered the interruption; no client service impact (the company's…
  • Trident IT Solutions · customer data requirement exposure documented; company able to comply, no loss carried
    a loss is carried only where the company says it cannot supply what is asked; the exposed base is shown for the story
03Top initiatives by company

The first three things to do at each company

Ranked by payback, quickest first; items that protect revenue earned today come before revenue not yet won. Colour tags the type of item.

Earns todayRevenue not yet wonEfficiency measureCompany planNot yet sized

Sterling Precision★priority

Industrial Technology · modelled exit October 2027 · expected loss $5.9M a year
Efficiency measureCompressed air system optimization
Cost $80KPayback 1.1 to 1.3 years$60K to $70K a year savedexit value effect $540Kpays back after the modelled exit
Efficiency measureComplete LED lighting retrofit, Akron and Elyria
Cost $120KPayback 1.5 years$80K a year savedexit value effect $720Kpays back after the modelled exit
Efficiency measureHeat recovery from heat treatment furnaces, Akron
Cost $250KPayback 3.1 to 4.2 years$60K to $80K a year savedexit value effect $540Kpays back after the modelled exit

Harvest Ridge Foods★priority

Food & Agriculture · modelled exit January 2030 · expected loss $2.4M a year
Earns todayRespond to customers' carbon-data requests
Cost $54K†Payback 18 to 33 days†$2.2M a year protected (half lost $1.1M)†earned revenue: counted at exit through the earnings it protects
Efficiency measureComplete LED lighting retrofit, Nashville, Bowling Green, Chattanooga
Cost $95KPayback 1.0 to 1.5 years$63K to $95K a year savedexit value effect $538K
Efficiency measureCompressed air audit and optimization
Cost $65KPayback 0.9 to 1.6 years$40K to $55K a year savedexit value effect $340K

Meridian Business Solutions★priority

Business Services · modelled exit October 2027 · expected loss $565K a year
No sized initiative yet

Clearview Environmental★priority

Environmental Services · modelled exit January 2028 · expected loss $647K a year
Efficiency measureFleet idle reduction
Cost $20K†Payback 1.0 to 2.1 years$10K to $19K a year savedexit value effect $92Kpays back after the modelled exit

Pinnacle Testing

Industrial Technology · modelled exit July 2029 · expected loss $1.8M a year
Earns todayRespond to customers' carbon-data requests
Cost $9K†Payback 9 to 18 days†$749K a year protected (half lost $375K)†earned revenue: counted at exit through the earnings it protects

Ridgeline Property Services

Real Estate Services · modelled exit January 2030 · expected loss $617K a year
Earns todayRespond to customers' carbon-data requests
Cost $45K†Payback 90 to 161 days†$363K a year protected (half lost $182K)†earned revenue: counted at exit through the earnings it protects
Company planNew service line for institutional clients (company plan)
Cost $1.8MPayback about 2 yearsrevenue, not profitnot capitalised

NovaCare Health Partners

Healthcare Services · modelled exit October 2027 · expected loss $516K a year
Efficiency measureHVAC replacement at the four PhysioFirst clinics
Cost $280K†Payback 2.3 to 7.0 years$40K to $123K a year savedexit value effect $400Kpays back after the modelled exit

Trident IT Solutions

Technology Services · modelled exit October 2027 · expected loss $433K a year
Efficiency measureSub-metering of the Cleveland SOC (evaluating for 2026)
Cost $3K†Payback 0.1 to 0.9 years$3K to $21K a year savedexit value effect $35K

Keystone Behavioral Health

Healthcare Services · modelled exit July 2029 · expected loss $426K a year
Efficiency measureEnergy Star appliances and LED fit-out standard for new clinics
Cost $5K†Payback 1.1 to 4.0 years$1K to $3K a year savedexit value effect $12Kpays back after the modelled exit

Patriot Staffing

Business Services · modelled exit April 2029 · expected loss $239K a year
Efficiency measureElectric vehicles for the branch manager fleet (evaluating)
Cost $56K†Payback 3.3 to 10.1 yearsabout $6K a year savedexit value effect $48Kpays back after the modelled exit
04Portfolio ranking

Every sized initiative in one ranked list

Efficiency measures are rated on the low end of savings and the high end of cost. Exit value is the annual saving times the company's exit multiple; hope-to-win revenue is never capitalised.

#CompanyInitiativeCostPaybackValue a yearExit valueFlag
1PinnacleEarns today Respond to customers' carbon-data requests$9K†9 to 18 days†$749K (half lost $375K)earns today: counted at exit
2Harvest Ridge★Earns today Respond to customers' carbon-data requests$54K†18 to 33 days†$2.2M (half lost $1.1M)earns today: counted at exit
3RidgelineEarns today Respond to customers' carbon-data requests$45K†90 to 161 days†$363K (half lost $182K)earns today: counted at exit
4TridentEfficiency measure Sub-metering of the Cleveland SOC (evaluating for 2026)$3K†0.1 to 0.9 years†$3K to $21K$35K
5Sterling★Efficiency measure Compressed air system optimization$80K1.1 to 1.3 years$60K to $70K$540Kafter exit
6Harvest Ridge★Efficiency measure Complete LED lighting retrofit, Nashville, Bowling Green, Chattanooga$95K1.0 to 1.5 years$63K to $95K$538K
7Harvest Ridge★Efficiency measure Compressed air audit and optimization$65K0.9 to 1.6 years$40K to $55K$340K
8Sterling★Efficiency measure Complete LED lighting retrofit, Akron and Elyria$120K1.5 years$80K$720Kafter exit
9Clearview★Efficiency measure Fleet idle reduction$20K†1.0 to 2.1 years†$10K to $19K$92Kafter exit
10Harvest Ridge★Efficiency measure Steam trap survey and repair program$35K1.0 to 2.3 years$15K to $25K$128K
11KeystoneEfficiency measure Energy Star appliances and LED fit-out standard for new clinics$5K†1.1 to 4.0 years†$1K to $3K$12Kafter exit
12Harvest Ridge★Efficiency measure Boiler economizers, Nashville and Bowling Green$240K2.7 to 3.4 years$70K to $90K$595Kafter exit
13Sterling★Efficiency measure Heat recovery from heat treatment furnaces, Akron$250K3.1 to 4.2 years$60K to $80K$540Kafter exit
14NovaCareEfficiency measure HVAC replacement at the four PhysioFirst clinics$280K†2.3 to 7.0 years†$40K to $123K$400Kafter exit
15PatriotEfficiency measure Electric vehicles for the branch manager fleet (evaluating)$56K†3.3 to 10.1 years†about $6K$48Kafter exit
16Sterling★Efficiency measure Solar PPA evaluation, Akron roof$345K†6.2 to 14.9 years†$23K to $55K$208Kafter exit
17Harvest Ridge★Efficiency measure Rooftop solar evaluation, Bowling Green$345K†6.2 to 14.9 years†$23K to $55K$197Kafter exit
18Sterling★Revenue not yet won Respond to customers' carbon-data requests$9K†1 to 2 days†$5.4M (half lost $2.7M)not capitalised
19RidgelineCompany plan New service line for institutional clients (company plan)$1.8Mabout 2 yearsrevenue, not profitnot capitalised
05Basis

Notes

Method notes
  • Report date October 9, 2026. Impact is against EBITDA for the twelve months to January 31, 2026.
  • Large and likely follow Northwood's own scale at their defaults: High impact from 15 percent of EBITDA, Likely from a 35 percent chance over the hold.
  • Cost to respond to customer data requests is a Kith estimate (†), built from two secondary benchmark pages with no independent project-fee check. Value protected is an upper what-if: the whole exposed revenue treated as lost; the half is a Kith illustration. It is not likelihood-weighted.
  • Revenue not yet won means exactly that; it is not in earnings and is not capitalised through the exit multiple.
  • Payback is shown as a range. Whether a buyer pays the exit multiple on a saving only months old is the open question.
  • All ten companies are ranked on the same rules. Items without a stated cost or saving are sized as grade C estimates from the DOE industrial assessment database and marked †.
How the estimates were made and checked
EstimateHow it was madeWhat it rests onCross-checkResult
Insurance premium (four companies with no premium figure; Keystone uses its own $285,000 premium as the base; its $20K† line is the estimated increase)Median of the five portfolio companies that state a 2025 premium, as a share of LTM revenue, times the US casualty rate change, applied to the whole premium as an upper bound0.29% of revenue (range 0.13% to 1.44%, n=5); casualty rate +7% (Marsh, Q2 2026)RIMS total cost of risk is 1.0% of revenue, 3.4 times the portfolio medianconsistent as an upper bound only
The RIMS figure includes retained losses and administration, so it overstates the premium; the observed portfolio ratio is used and RIMS is kept as the ceiling.
Supplier concentration (eight companies without a supplier file)McKinsey Global Institute: more than 40% of a year's profit lost per decade over a disruption every 3.7 years, scaled by a dependence factor of 0.25 (people and facility services) or 0.5 (equipment and consumables)14.8% of one year's EBITDA per disruption before scaling; resulting impacts 3.7% to 7.4% of EBITDACompany-specific sole-source impacts from supplier files: sterling 15.2% of EBITDA; harvest 18.1% of EBITDAconsistent in size, not independent
The two goods makers with their own supplier files sit at 15 to 18% of EBITDA per disruption, at or just above the 14.8% benchmark. Both are Kith's own one-lead-time calculation, so this is a consistency check, not independent evidence; the service companies are scaled down by judgment, so confidence is low.
Efficiency measures without a stated cost or saving (solar, HVAC saving, lighting, sub-metering)Median cost and payback quartiles of the matching recommendation code in the DOE industrial assessment databaselighting 1.1 to 4.0 years (n=19,471); HVAC 2.3 to 7.0 (n=1,044); solar 6.2 to 14.9 (n=1,590); sub-metering 0.1 to 0.9 (n=28)Paybacks computed by Kith from the lighting costs and savings two companies state: sterling 1.5 years; harvest 1.0 to 1.5 years2 of 2 conservative company paybacks sit inside the lighting range
The comparison covers lighting only, because no company states a solar or HVAC saving; the benchmark is untested on those.
Water price (Harvest Ridge)Median supply price of TN and KY plants in the DOE industrial assessment database$4.16 per 1,000 gallons (n=186)Context: Nashville raised rates 3% in 2026, the sixth straight annual rise; US typical combined bill +4.6% in 2024 (Bluefield)small in any case
Even doubling the price leaves the line under half a percent of EBITDA; sewer charges are excluded.
Patriot electric vehiclesEight vehicles at the national average mileage, the signed 2025 gasoline price, EPA mpg and EV energy use; cost eight times the EV price gap260,780 miles per vehicle would be implied by the reported 76,700 gallonsFHWA average: 11,026 miles a year for cars, 11,360 for SUVs, pickups and vansreported fuel does not fit eight vehicles
The reported fuel is not used; the first move says to check the fleet's mileage first.
Reference input: DOE industrial assessment database, recommendation code 2.9114Quartiles of implementation cost over annual saving across the recommendations with both stated; median costn=1,590; median cost $344,510; payback 6.21 / 9.43 / 14.90 years (25th / median / 75th)DOE industrial assessment database (pinned reference file), recommendations sheet: recommendation code, implementation cost, annual savingcomputed from the pinned file
Recomputed on every run; nothing typed.
Reference input: DOE industrial assessment database, recommendation code 2.7232Quartiles of implementation cost over annual saving across the recommendations with both stated; median costn=1,044; median cost $21,464; payback 2.28 / 4.29 / 7.00 years (25th / median / 75th)DOE industrial assessment database (pinned reference file), recommendations sheet: recommendation code, implementation cost, annual savingcomputed from the pinned file
Recomputed on every run; nothing typed.
Reference input: DOE industrial assessment database, recommendation code 2.8117Quartiles of implementation cost over annual saving across the recommendations with both stated; median costn=28; median cost $3,000; payback 0.14 / 0.54 / 0.90 years (25th / median / 75th)DOE industrial assessment database (pinned reference file), recommendations sheet: recommendation code, implementation cost, annual savingcomputed from the pinned file
Recomputed on every run; nothing typed.
Reference input: DOE industrial assessment database, recommendation code 2.7142Quartiles of implementation cost over annual saving across the recommendations with both stated; median costn=19,471; median cost $4,082; payback 1.10 / 2.26 / 4.02 years (25th / median / 75th)DOE industrial assessment database (pinned reference file), recommendations sheet: recommendation code, implementation cost, annual savingcomputed from the pinned file
Recomputed on every run; nothing typed.
Reference input: industrial water price, Tennessee and KentuckyMedian of water consumption cost over usage across plants in the DOE database$4.16 per 1,000 gallons; n=186; assessments FY2016 to FY2026DOE industrial assessment database (pinned reference file), assessments sheet: state, water consumption cost, water usagecomputed from the pinned file
Supply price only; sewer charges are not included, so the line is a floor.
Reference input: regular gasoline priceThe signed 2025 weekly average of the EIA series 'Weekly U.S. Regular All Formulations Retail Gasoline Prices' (52 weeks)$3.097 per gallonthe signed assumptions table (assumption G2-A8) and the pinned EIA weekly gasoline fileread from the signed assumption
The same price the fleet-fuel measure at Clearview uses.
Reference input: commercial electricity priceThe U.S. Total row of the EIA commercial price table14.53 cents per kWhthe pinned EIA average retail price table, U.S. Total rowread from the pinned file
Used for the EV electricity cost.
Customer data requirement, ClearviewThe company's own estimate of $2-3M of contract value forgone in 2025, valued at gross profit, recurrence Likely$2.5M midpointCompany states 40-50% of revenue comes from clients with environmental commitments: not used as a loss, only as contextcompany-stated
Based on an observed loss, so more grounded than a share-of-revenue what-if.
Customer data requirement, MeridianThe two requesting clients at the average customer's size145 customers on $225M revenue; top customer 11%Upper bound: two clients at the top-customer share = $50Mderived, low confidence
The company states no figure, so the base is derived; the range is shown on the line.