|Kith Consulting
← All documentsPortfolio edition · fictional client
01The answer

Ten companies, one question: what moves what a buyer pays?

We connected each company's footprint to its financials, sized the exposures in dollars, ranked them, and costed the response. This is what it says.

The ten companies carry $13.5M a year of expected loss: $7.9M on earnings they already have and $5.6M on revenue not yet won. Three of them (Sterling, Harvest Ridge, Pinnacle) hold about 75% of it. 5 of 46 exposures (the 10 carbon-price scenarios are left out) are large enough to act on; the rest need watching.

$13.5M
expected loss a year, in total
$7.9M
of it on earnings in hand; $5.6M on revenue not yet won
18
initiatives sized and ranked, plus one company growth plan
10
companies, priority four marked ★

Report date October 9, 2026Expected loss shown at everything lost, with half lost and earns-today splits beside it

02What we built

Six pieces that fit together

Each piece reads from the one before it, so a number on any page traces back to the data room or to a labelled Kith estimate.

Connected datasetEach company's carbon footprint beside its revenue, EBITDA, margin, multiple and remaining hold.
Exposure modelSix exposures per company in dollars a year: impact, chance, expected loss, and a grade for every figure.
Extended dataA simulated water and site baseline for Harvest Ridge Foods, labelled simulated and kept apart from every other figure.
Materiality matrixEvery exposure placed by chance and size against EBITDA, using Northwood's own cut-offs.
Initiative rankingWhat to do first at each company: cost, payback, value, and what a buyer might credit at exit.
ExplorerOne page to move the exit year and the thresholds and open any company.
03Where it sits

Three companies carry about 75% of the expected loss

Expected loss a year at everything lost (pale) and half lost (solid). The priority four hold 71% of the total.

Sterling Precision★
$5.9M / $3.2M
Harvest Ridge Foods★
$2.4M / $1.3M
Clearview Environmental★
$647K / $556K
Meridian Business Solutions★
$565K / $460K
Pinnacle Testing
$1.8M / $1.4M
Ridgeline Property Services
$617K / $436K
NovaCare Health Partners
$516K / $516K
Trident IT Solutions
$433K / $433K
Keystone Behavioral Health
$426K / $426K
Patriot Staffing
$239K / $239K
04The matrix

Most exposures are small; a handful are not

Each dot is one exposure at one company: how likely over the remaining hold, and how big against its EBITDA. Dashed lines are Northwood's cut-offs (15% of EBITDA, 35% chance).

0.01%0.1%1%5%15%30%100%0%25%50%75%100%chance over the remaining holdimpact, % of EBITDA (log scale)Hedge or insureMitigate nowDeprioritizeAccept and monitor53412
Mitigate now2Likely and large. Capital and management time go here first.
Hedge or insure3Unlikely but large. Transfer the risk: insurance, hedges, contract terms.
Accept and monitor19Likely but small. Watch the trend; do not spend capital on it yet.
Deprioritize22Unlikely and small. Note it; revisit once a year.

Hover any dot for its detail. The numbered dots are the large exposures, listed on the next page.

05The large exposures

The 5 exposures that are large enough to act on

These are the only points in the upper half of the matrix. 2 are likely: spend on them. 3 are unlikely but would hurt: transfer the risk.

1Harvest Ridge Foods★

Mitigate now

$11.3M

customer data requirement: 49% of EBITDA, 50% chance over the hold. Expected loss $2.2M a year.

2Pinnacle Testing

Hedge or insure

$8.4M

customer data requirement: 42% of EBITDA, 22% chance over the hold. Expected loss $749K a year.

3Sterling Precision★

Mitigate now

$10.9M

customer data requirement: 36% of EBITDA, 50% chance over the hold. Expected loss $5.4M a year. This is revenue not yet won, not earnings in hand.

4Harvest Ridge Foods★

Hedge or insure

$4.1M

sole-source supplier: 18% of EBITDA, 5% chance over the hold. Expected loss $65K a year.

5Sterling Precision★

Hedge or insure

$4.6M

sole-source supplier: 15% of EBITDA, 5% chance over the hold. Expected loss $230K a year.

06Customer data requests

Customers are asking for carbon data, and answering is cheap next to what it protects

4 companies have a sized response to customers' data requests (Meridian and Clearview carry the exposure without one). Answering all of them costs about $117K in total and reduces expected loss by up to $8.7M a year (chance-weighted, if the exposed revenue were lost; $4.4M at half lost, Kith's illustration); $5.4M of that is on revenue not yet won. Only revenue the company earns today is counted toward exit value.

CompanyRevenueCost to respondPaybackProtects a year of profit, all lostProtects a year of profit, half lost
PinnacleEarns today$9K†9 to 18 days†$749K$375K
Harvest Ridge★Earns today$54K†18 to 33 days†$2.2M$1.1M
RidgelineEarns today$45K†90 to 161 days†$363K$182K
Sterling★Revenue not yet won$9K†1 to 2 days†$5.4M$2.7M
07Efficiency measures

Which energy measures pay back before the modelled exit

Bars show the payback range; the orange line is the company's modelled exit. 10 of 14 measures reach payback after it, so a buyer would have to credit the saving.

Trident
Sub-metering of the Cleveland SOC…
0.1 to 0.9 years†
Sterling★
Compressed air system optimization
1.1 to 1.3 years
Harvest Ridge★
Complete LED lighting retrofit, Nashville…
1.0 to 1.5 years
Harvest Ridge★
Compressed air audit and optimization
0.9 to 1.6 years
Sterling★
Complete LED lighting retrofit, Akron and…
1.5 years
Clearview★
Fleet idle reduction
1.0 to 2.1 years†
Harvest Ridge★
Steam trap survey and repair program
1.0 to 2.3 years
Keystone
Energy Star appliances and LED fit-out…
1.1 to 4.0 years†
Harvest Ridge★
Boiler economizers, Nashville and Bowling…
2.7 to 3.4 years
Sterling★
Heat recovery from heat treatment furnaces…
3.1 to 4.2 years
NovaCare
HVAC replacement at the four PhysioFirst…
2.3 to 7.0 years†
Patriot
Electric vehicles for the branch manager…
3.3 to 10.1 years†
Sterling★
Solar PPA evaluation, Akron roof
6.2 to 14.9 years†
Harvest Ridge★
Rooftop solar evaluation, Bowling Green
6.2 to 14.9 years†

Rated on the low end of savings and the high end of cost.

08What to do first

The first six items on the ranked list

Quickest payback first, with revenue earned today ahead of revenue not yet won. The full ranked list is in the matrix and initiatives page. “Exit value effect” is the low-end annual saving times the company’s exit multiple; whether a buyer pays that multiple is a judgment.

Earns todayRespond to customers' carbon-data requests
Cost $9K†Payback 9 to 18 days†$749K a year protected (half lost $375K)†earned revenue: counted at exit through the earnings it protects
Earns todayRespond to customers' carbon-data requests
Cost $54K†Payback 18 to 33 days†$2.2M a year protected (half lost $1.1M)†earned revenue: counted at exit through the earnings it protects
Earns todayRespond to customers' carbon-data requests
Cost $45K†Payback 90 to 161 days†$363K a year protected (half lost $182K)†earned revenue: counted at exit through the earnings it protects
Efficiency measureSub-metering of the Cleveland SOC (evaluating for 2026)
Cost $3K†Payback 0.1 to 0.9 years$3K to $21K a year savedexit value effect $35K
Efficiency measureCompressed air system optimization
Cost $80KPayback 1.1 to 1.3 years$60K to $70K a year savedexit value effect $540Kpays back after the modelled exit
Efficiency measureComplete LED lighting retrofit, Nashville, Bowling Green, Chattanooga
Cost $95KPayback 1.0 to 1.5 years$63K to $95K a year savedexit value effect $538K
09Exit timing

When each company is modelled to exit

This is Kith's model, the report date plus the remaining hold, not a Northwood plan. Where a hold is a floor of one year it is the earliest modelled date. Where Northwood's own plan differs, use that.

2027202820292030Sterling Precision ★October 2027 · $5.9M a yearMeridian Business Solutions ★October 2027 · $565K a yearNovaCare Health PartnersOctober 2027 · $516K a yearTrident IT SolutionsOctober 2027 · $433K a yearClearview Environmental ★January 2028 · $647K a yearPatriot StaffingApril 2029 · $239K a yearKeystone Behavioral HealthJuly 2029 · $426K a yearPinnacle TestingJuly 2029 · $1.8M a yearHarvest Ridge Foods ★January 2030 · $2.4M a yearRidgeline Property ServicesJanuary 2030 · $617K a year
10Priority four and the rest

How the priority four compare with the other six

All ten are modelled on the same rules, so the six others can be read the same way.

Priority four ★

$9.6M

expected loss a year (71% of the total; figures are rounded, so parts may not add exactly). 12 of the 18 sized initiatives. Sterling, Harvest Ridge, Meridian, Clearview.

The other six

$4.0M

expected loss a year. 6 sized initiatives. Keystone, NovaCare, Patriot, Pinnacle, Ridgeline, Trident.

11How much to trust it

Every figure carries a grade; the weakest are marked †

Of 56 exposure lines with a dollar figure, 51 rest on a Kith estimate (†), 5 on a company-reported figure and 0 on official data; 13 of the Kith estimates were built from published benchmarks where the data room was silent. 6 more lines have no figure because the company reported no loss or no exposure; they are listed, not estimated.

A Grade A

Official published data, or an actual from a system of record.

B Grade B

A figure the company reported, an accounting estimate, or a value derived from A and B inputs.

C Grade C

Judgment, a proxy, undated or simulated data. A Kith estimate: no outside source or company has confirmed it. Marked †.

How the estimates were made and checked
EstimateHow it was madeWhat it rests onCross-checkResult
Insurance premium (four companies with no premium figure; Keystone uses its own $285,000 premium as the base; its $20K† line is the estimated increase)Median of the five portfolio companies that state a 2025 premium, as a share of LTM revenue, times the US casualty rate change, applied to the whole premium as an upper bound0.29% of revenue (range 0.13% to 1.44%, n=5); casualty rate +7% (Marsh, Q2 2026)RIMS total cost of risk is 1.0% of revenue, 3.4 times the portfolio medianconsistent as an upper bound only
The RIMS figure includes retained losses and administration, so it overstates the premium; the observed portfolio ratio is used and RIMS is kept as the ceiling.
Supplier concentration (eight companies without a supplier file)McKinsey Global Institute: more than 40% of a year's profit lost per decade over a disruption every 3.7 years, scaled by a dependence factor of 0.25 (people and facility services) or 0.5 (equipment and consumables)14.8% of one year's EBITDA per disruption before scaling; resulting impacts 3.7% to 7.4% of EBITDACompany-specific sole-source impacts from supplier files: sterling 15.2% of EBITDA; harvest 18.1% of EBITDAconsistent in size, not independent
The two goods makers with their own supplier files sit at 15 to 18% of EBITDA per disruption, at or just above the 14.8% benchmark. Both are Kith's own one-lead-time calculation, so this is a consistency check, not independent evidence; the service companies are scaled down by judgment, so confidence is low.
Efficiency measures without a stated cost or saving (solar, HVAC saving, lighting, sub-metering)Median cost and payback quartiles of the matching recommendation code in the DOE industrial assessment databaselighting 1.1 to 4.0 years (n=19,471); HVAC 2.3 to 7.0 (n=1,044); solar 6.2 to 14.9 (n=1,590); sub-metering 0.1 to 0.9 (n=28)Paybacks computed by Kith from the lighting costs and savings two companies state: sterling 1.5 years; harvest 1.0 to 1.5 years2 of 2 conservative company paybacks sit inside the lighting range
The comparison covers lighting only, because no company states a solar or HVAC saving; the benchmark is untested on those.
Water price (Harvest Ridge)Median supply price of TN and KY plants in the DOE industrial assessment database$4.16 per 1,000 gallons (n=186)Context: Nashville raised rates 3% in 2026, the sixth straight annual rise; US typical combined bill +4.6% in 2024 (Bluefield)small in any case
Even doubling the price leaves the line under half a percent of EBITDA; sewer charges are excluded.
Patriot electric vehiclesEight vehicles at the national average mileage, the signed 2025 gasoline price, EPA mpg and EV energy use; cost eight times the EV price gap260,780 miles per vehicle would be implied by the reported 76,700 gallonsFHWA average: 11,026 miles a year for cars, 11,360 for SUVs, pickups and vansreported fuel does not fit eight vehicles
The reported fuel is not used; the first move says to check the fleet's mileage first.
Reference input: DOE industrial assessment database, recommendation code 2.9114Quartiles of implementation cost over annual saving across the recommendations with both stated; median costn=1,590; median cost $344,510; payback 6.21 / 9.43 / 14.90 years (25th / median / 75th)DOE industrial assessment database (pinned reference file), recommendations sheet: recommendation code, implementation cost, annual savingcomputed from the pinned file
Recomputed on every run; nothing typed.
Reference input: DOE industrial assessment database, recommendation code 2.7232Quartiles of implementation cost over annual saving across the recommendations with both stated; median costn=1,044; median cost $21,464; payback 2.28 / 4.29 / 7.00 years (25th / median / 75th)DOE industrial assessment database (pinned reference file), recommendations sheet: recommendation code, implementation cost, annual savingcomputed from the pinned file
Recomputed on every run; nothing typed.
Reference input: DOE industrial assessment database, recommendation code 2.8117Quartiles of implementation cost over annual saving across the recommendations with both stated; median costn=28; median cost $3,000; payback 0.14 / 0.54 / 0.90 years (25th / median / 75th)DOE industrial assessment database (pinned reference file), recommendations sheet: recommendation code, implementation cost, annual savingcomputed from the pinned file
Recomputed on every run; nothing typed.
Reference input: DOE industrial assessment database, recommendation code 2.7142Quartiles of implementation cost over annual saving across the recommendations with both stated; median costn=19,471; median cost $4,082; payback 1.10 / 2.26 / 4.02 years (25th / median / 75th)DOE industrial assessment database (pinned reference file), recommendations sheet: recommendation code, implementation cost, annual savingcomputed from the pinned file
Recomputed on every run; nothing typed.
Reference input: industrial water price, Tennessee and KentuckyMedian of water consumption cost over usage across plants in the DOE database$4.16 per 1,000 gallons; n=186; assessments FY2016 to FY2026DOE industrial assessment database (pinned reference file), assessments sheet: state, water consumption cost, water usagecomputed from the pinned file
Supply price only; sewer charges are not included, so the line is a floor.
Reference input: regular gasoline priceThe signed 2025 weekly average of the EIA series 'Weekly U.S. Regular All Formulations Retail Gasoline Prices' (52 weeks)$3.097 per gallonthe signed assumptions table (assumption G2-A8) and the pinned EIA weekly gasoline fileread from the signed assumption
The same price the fleet-fuel measure at Clearview uses.
Reference input: commercial electricity priceThe U.S. Total row of the EIA commercial price table14.53 cents per kWhthe pinned EIA average retail price table, U.S. Total rowread from the pinned file
Used for the EV electricity cost.
Customer data requirement, ClearviewThe company's own estimate of $2-3M of contract value forgone in 2025, valued at gross profit, recurrence Likely$2.5M midpointCompany states 40-50% of revenue comes from clients with environmental commitments: not used as a loss, only as contextcompany-stated
Based on an observed loss, so more grounded than a share-of-revenue what-if.
Customer data requirement, MeridianThe two requesting clients at the average customer's size145 customers on $225M revenue; top customer 11%Upper bound: two clients at the top-customer share = $50Mderived, low confidence
The company states no figure, so the base is derived; the range is shown on the line.
What else to know
  • The exit dates, owners and first moves are Kith proposals, not Northwood plans.
  • The cost to respond to customers is a Kith estimate from two secondary benchmark pages, with no independent project-fee check.
  • The weather lines of Keystone, NovaCare, Patriot, Pinnacle, Ridgeline and Trident were re-derived by an independent check script; the others are model-run.
  • Derived energy is a low case. The insurance estimate uses the portfolio's own observed premium ratio, and says so.
12Caveats

Nine things to keep in mind when you use these numbers

The work is complete as it stands; these are the limits of what it can tell you.

Exit dates are Kith's modelEach is the report date plus the remaining hold, with 4 held at a one-year floor. Which exposures fall inside a hold depends on it. Where Northwood's own plan differs, use that.
Owners and first moves are proposalsThey come from roles named in the company files, adjacent roles, or Kith's own suggestion, each tagged by basis. None was confirmed with a company.
Cost to respond is an estimate †Built from two benchmark pages. The paybacks in days assume the half-lost case, which is an illustration, not a forecast.
Revenue not yet won is never bankedHope-to-win revenue sizes what is at stake. It is not in earnings and is never counted toward exit value.
Estimates fill the gaps, and say so51 of 56 exposure lines rest on Kith estimates (grade C); 13 of them were built from published benchmarks where the data room was silent. All are marked † and tagged. They are low confidence: they rank and size, they do not quote.
How the totals workThe company total is the sum of its lines, leaving out the carbon-price scenario because it overlaps the energy line. Lines can strike in the same year, so the total is an average expected loss, not a worst case.
A Harvest Ridge drought line on simulated valuesThe drought curtailment line rests in part on simulated plant values, by a specific exception to the rule that keeps simulated data out of other figures; it is a scenario, not an observed drought link, and the water authority attributed the 2025 pressure drops to demand and maintenance. The water price line uses the reported 28M gallons.
Patriot's exit is the base caseIts files give 2027 to 2028 as a target and the first half of 2029 as the base case; the model uses 2029 because the target needs $32M to $38M of EBITDA against $23.8M today. A 2027 exit would shorten its hold.
Totals are cases, not forecasts$13.5M is expected loss with all exposed customer revenue lost and $9.0M at half lost; $5.6M of the total is revenue not yet won.
13Where to find it

The rest of the delivery

Every figure on these pages is in the exposure model and the matrix and initiatives page, with its grade; the explorer lets you test them.

14Back-end note: how it was built

Everything in the build is one of six things, and each number has a trail

This note is for whoever audits or maintains the work. It shows what each part of the process does and how the parts link, without opening a single script. Counts are the record as at 11 October 2026, before the final (G7) freeze.

THE TRAIL FOR EVERY NUMBER: rule, script, check, review, decision, record1. Rules16 rules in the chartersay what must be true2. Scripts24 run-order stepsmake every output file3. Checks65 gate checks, 33 seeded teststest the rules; can stop the build4. Reviewers6 reviewer rolesread-only agents; raise findings5. Decisions180 logged, datedthe owner's words, as given6. Record289 chained entriesappend-only; an edit breaks the chain

Rules

The charter's 16 rules say what must be true: units, scenarios, bands, missing data, ranking, simulated data and the customer data requirement. Nothing on a page departs from them unless a dated decision says so.

Scripts

24 run-order steps (87 script versions are kept) build every file from the data room and the reference data. They stop with a plain message if an input, header or period no longer matches, and never overwrite.

Checks

Gate checks re-derive figures from source and fail on a defect; each is proved with seeded failures before it is trusted (33 test files). A check that passes is stronger evidence than a reviewer's opinion.

Reviewers

Reviewer agents, each read-only and given one question, work from the same packet: Evidence review, Audience read, Presentation review, Method review, Process review. They raise findings; they cannot change a file.

Decisions

180 decisions are logged with the date and channel, and the owner's words wherever the owner decided. A builder's proposal is marked proposed until the owner ratifies it.

The record

289 entries are linked to one another, so an earlier entry cannot be altered without breaking the chain. 259 journal entries say what was done, why, and what was left open.

15Back-end note: gates and review

8 gates, each closed only when its checks pass and the owner signs

Each gate froze the files it covered. Where a check failed or a reviewer raised a must-fix finding, the work went back, was versioned and re-run. Dates are when each gate was frozen; findings are those raised at that gate.

GateClosedChecksReviewersMust-fix raisedShould-fix raisedFiles frozen
G0 Foundations2026-10-0910Process review224378
G1 Data and models2026-10-0925Method review, Evidence review49100
G2 Outputs2026-10-0920Evidence review, Presentation review, Audience read526104
G3 Close2026-10-0914Process review86103
G4 Rebuild2026-10-1022Evidence review, Method review, Process review924250
G5 Explorer2026-10-1110Evidence review, Audience read317176
G6 Handover2026-10-1112Process review36175
G7 Revision and final deliverysigned and frozen 11 October 202613Method review, Evidence review, Audience read, Process review38 findings, all fixed52

Gate G7 covers the revision of this delivery set after G6: the decisions logged after G6, a delivery check with seeded failures, and a reviewer round on method, evidence, audience and process before it was frozen. What was not reviewed: there was no Presentation-lane read of the final pages; the counts in this note are the record at the date shown and are not recomputed; and fixes made after the G7 round were re-run through the delivery check and the re-run test, not re-reviewed.

16Back-end note: what was caught

223 findings were raised on this build; 205 are fixed and every one has a recorded reason

Reviewers worked from the same packet, read-only, with one question each. These are examples of what they caught, in plain terms.

223
findings raised, by reviewers and by the builder
205
fixed, with a recorded reason
8
accepted or deferred, with a reason
10
still open (process items)

G0 · Process review must-fix

Caught: A five-year forward hold was applied to every company, but Sterling is already 5.7 years in and Meridian exits in the first quarter of 2027.

Done: Hold years are now set per company from its documented exit plan.

G1 · Evidence review must-fix

Caught: Clearview's weather events were counted over one year when the company lists three, which overstated how likely they are.

Done: The window is now the three years the company reports.

G4 · Evidence review must-fix

Caught: Ridgeline's growth-plan investment was stated in its own plan, but the model said it was not stated.

Done: Quantified from the plan's own investment table and shown as a company plan, not capitalised.

G4 · Method review must-fix

Caught: Ridgeline's weather impact had been taken as a property owner's cost, not Ridgeline's own.

Done: Carried as Ridgeline's own small event; the owner-borne losses are shown as context.

G4 · Method review must-fix

Caught: Pinnacle's largest event had combined two storms, lifting its severity band.

Done: Apportioned by closure days; the combined figure is shown only as an upper bound.

G5 · Audience read must-fix

Caught: Exit dates were labelled 'planned exit' though they are Kith's model, not a Northwood plan.

Done: Relabelled 'modelled exit', with floors marked as the earliest modelled date.

G5 · Audience read must-fix

Caught: Paybacks in days and exit values read as sized benefits though they rest on a what-if.

Done: Labelled 'if the half-lost case happens' and 'what-if, not likelihood-weighted'.

G6 · Process review must-fix

Caught: The decision list shipped to the client was missing most decisions its own files cite.

Done: Rebuilt from the record so every cited decision is present.

Who raised what
  • Process review: 100
  • Evidence review: 36
  • Audience read: 33
  • Method review: 30
  • Builder: 12
  • Presentation review: 11
  • Builder (held-out check): 1