Kith Consulting · Week 3 leave-behind
Rendered copy of the signed methodology note (methodology-note-v6.md, sha256 5293ebd455e3). Portfolio edition: Kith Climate cohort case, fictional client. Small grey tags such as J-081 point to entries in the project record (journal, findings, decisions), so every statement can be traced.

Methodology note: how Northwood's carbon inventory is calculated

Version 6, 5 October 2026 (replaces v5; names every number decision taken with results in view, finding F-128. Earlier: v5 replaced v4; adds the ledger lineage gaps to the known limits, finding F-124. Earlier: v4 replaced v3; corrects the statement that no result could steer the method, finding F-113, and lists the number decisions made after results were visible. Earlier: v3 stated that dashboard v14 carries the roster label that v13 lacked, finding F-110; v2 and v1 are in _archive. Earlier: v2 replaced v1; adds the traceability pass, in which each statement that rests on a fact, number or rule carries a tag such as M-07 pointing to its row in the claims register, and a separate check re-tests every row against the record). One of three leave-behind documents, with the reference data pack (where every outside number comes from) and the re-run note (how to update everything next quarter).

The test this note is written to pass: if Northwood had to reproduce or update the inventory next quarter with no access to Kith, could they, using only what is left behind? This note says what is calculated and why. It does not repeat the numbers; the dashboard and the calculation ledger hold those. Where a rule is a judgment call, the note says whose judgment and where it is recorded.

1. What the inventory covers

2. Conventions that apply everywhere

3. The calculation, step by step

Every calculation line is one site and one fuel or energy type. The template columns are electricity in kWh, natural gas in therms, diesel, gasoline and propane in gallons, and fleet diesel and fleet gasoline in gallons. For each line: M-36

  1. Read the number the company reported from the carbon collection template, after the repair and correction rules in section 4.
  2. Convert it to the unit the factor uses. Natural gas: 1 therm = 0.1 million Btu (mmBtu). Electricity: kWh divided by 1,000 gives MWh. M-37, M-38
  3. Multiply by the emission factor for that fuel or grid region. Each factor has a carbon dioxide, methane and nitrous oxide part. Fleet fuel uses the mobile carbon dioxide factor only (see section 1). M-39
  4. Convert methane and nitrous oxide to carbon-dioxide equivalent (CO2e) with the global warming potentials: methane 28 and nitrous oxide 265 (IPCC Fifth Assessment, 100 years). Add the three parts. M-40, M-41
  5. Record the line with its data citation, its factor citation, the rules and decisions that applied, its grade and its confidence label. Values are kept to six decimal places in the ledger; rounding happens only when figures are displayed. M-42

Electricity factors depend on where the site is. Each site is placed in an eGRID subregion by finding which subregion boundary contains its coordinates (decision D-P2). A site in no boundary takes the nearest one if it is within 5 kilometres, and is flagged as assigned by fallback; beyond 5 kilometres it stays unassigned and is listed as a data gap. M-43, M-44, M-45, M-46

Refrigerant leakage is counted in the base in two ways (rule R9). Where the company has a service record, the recharge amount is the leakage (graded A, Reported). Otherwise the leakage is the equipment charge times the EPA default annual leak rate for that equipment type (the screening method; graded C, Inferred). The CO2e is pounds leaked times 0.45359237 kilograms per pound times the refrigerant's GWP. The full charge is shown beside the total as an upper bound and never enters the base. M-47, M-48, M-49, M-50, M-51, M-52

Three worked examples from the ledger (checked against the file on 4 October 2026)

Natural gas, Sterling site SPM-001Electricity, Sterling site SPM-001Refrigerant, NovaCare site NC-028
Reported amount178,500 therms4,185,000 kWh10 lb of R-410A recharged (service record) M-53
Converted17,850 mmBtu4,185 MWh4.536 kg M-54
Factor53.06 kg CO2 per mmBtu (EPA Hub 2025)911.321 lb CO2 per MWh (eGRID2023, subregion RFCW)GWP 1,924 (IPCC AR5 via EPA Hub 2025) M-55
CO2947,121 kg4,185 x 911.321 x 0.45359237 = 1,729,946 kgnot split M-56
CH4 and N2O17.85 kg and 1.785 kg134.78 kg and 18.98 kgnot split M-57
CO2e948,094 kg1,738,750 kg8,727 kg M-58
Grade, labelA, ReportedA, ReportedA, Reported M-59

Electricity factors are published in pounds per MWh, which is why the pound-to-kilogram conversion appears.

4. Repairs, corrections and gaps in the company data

5. How the base, low and high cases are built

Each site gets a disposition from reconciling the roster against the company's own records (rule R1). The disposition decides which cases a line enters. M-70

DispositionMeaningBaseLowHigh
consistent, consistent-partial-year, ambiguous, untestableThe company's records support it, or are silentininin M-71
hold-unverifiedAbsent from the company's own complete site list; no evidence either wayin, flaggedoutin M-72
hold-contradictedThe company's own records say it was not operating in 2025outoutin M-73

"Untestable" means the company's records give no site list, so the roster cannot be tested at all. It is not the same as "fine". Wherever the high case is shown it carries the label that it excludes the sites missing from the roster, because it reads like an upper bound but cannot include sites with no data. Where a company's records give no site list, the rule (D-R1-A1) is that its figure is a single base number with the label "roster unverified at site level" beside it. Five companies are in that position: Clearview, Meridian, Pinnacle and Sterling (100 percent of base emissions on rows the company's records cannot test) and Keystone (95.6 percent). Dashboard v14 and the evidence view show the label beside those figures (finding F-110, closed when Daniel re-signed dashboard v14). M-74, M-75, M-76, M-77, M-78, M-79, M-80

6. Sensitivities (the pre-registered alternatives)

Each is a separate set of lines, tagged, pointing at the base lines it replaces. None enters a base total.

TagWhat it tests
boundary_swingEach site within 25 km of an eGRID boundary (and the sites in multi-subregion areas) re-run with the nearest different subregion's factor M-81
clearview_115Clearview's fleet fuel scaled from the 85 vehicles it reported to the 115 on its board deck. This is a scaling, never data. The 18 drilling rigs are not estimated M-82, M-83
r10_as_submittedNovaCare's two corrected rows as submitted M-84
r9_full_chargeRefrigerant at full charge rather than leakage M-85
fleet_ch4_n2o_boundFleet methane and nitrous oxide, using EPA's stationary per-gallon factors as a stand-in. A bound on what is left out, not a swing M-86
r2_alternativeThe questionnaire figure where it differs from the ledger by more than 5 percent M-87

An AR6 refrigerant sensitivity is pre-registered for any company whose refrigerant leakage exceeds 5 percent of its base Scope 1 and 2 (decision D-P3-R). It has not been triggered for any company in this build. M-88, M-89

7. Data-quality grades and flagged rows (rule R13)

8. Intensity, rankings and financial exposure

9. Scope 3 flags

Scope 3 is not calculated. Each company has a ranked list of the Scope 3 categories most likely to matter to it, with a materiality level, the basis (described by the company, or inferred from its business model), the evidence line in the data room, and what data would improve the flag. These are flags for planning data collection. They are not estimates. M-115

10. Inputs written by hand, and what a new year means

Three input files were built by reading the data room and citing the line for each value:

For a new year, these must be redone by hand, and the build scripts name them in the code. The same applies to the roster reconciliation (re-run it against the new roster and review each disposition change), the data corrections, the refrigerant evidence, the questionnaire totals and fills, and the data-gap list. The re-run note lists the order. M-119

11. Known limits and unverified items

12. How to trace any figure

Every number the dashboard shows has a figure ID. The calculation ledger lists every line behind it with the exact row of the carbon template, the exact factor row, the rule and decision IDs, the grade and the label. A check confirms that every displayed figure resolves to ledger lines and equals their sum (no orphan numbers), and that every pre-registered alternative appears beside its base figure. An independent recomputation, written separately from the calculator, rebuilds every line from the raw template and agrees to within 0.001 kg CO2e per facility. The build record (methodology/build-record-live.md) holds the run log, the decisions and their reasons, and the findings and how each was settled. M-130, M-131, M-132, M-133

Each statement in this note that rests on a fact, number or rule carries a tag such as M-07. The claims register (traceability-register-v5.csv) gives the evidence for each tag (a decision, a settings value, a ledger line, a file or a journal entry), and the check check-traceability-v5.py re-tests every row against the record.

13. The rules at a glance

RulePlain statement
R1The roster is not the boundary. Every site gets a disposition. Where evidence points both ways, show a base figure with a low-to-high range M-134
R2Source order when files conflict; show both where they differ by more than 5 percent M-135
R3Fund roll-up uses ownership months; company pages use the full year M-136
R4Denominators come from the spine, as of 31 January 2026; the alternative is shown M-137
R5Flag fleet fuel outside half to double the federal class average; Clearview scaled to 115 vehicles as a sensitivity M-138
R6Flag client data older than 90 days at the report date; reference data is not flagged M-139
R7Confirmed, Reported, Inferred; totals take the weakest label M-140
R8Ridgeline's own footprint only (six offices on the roster, a seventh is a roster gap); managed buildings separate M-141
R9Refrigerant leakage in the base, full charge as an upper bound, R-22 on its own line M-142
R10Use the corrected-by-evidence figure with the as-submitted figure beside it M-143
R11Sites missing from the roster are excluded and disclosed, never estimated M-144
R12Operational control; 100 percent of each company for the months owned M-145
R13Grade each row, site and company by data source; flag Grade C M-146
R14Carbon-price exposure at three scenario prices, as a share of EBITDA, with the EU-benchmark note M-147